Arts & Letters
Which composer's Fourth Symphony was withdrawn after a Soviet denunciation and hidden for 25 years?
- Shostakovich
- Prokofiev
- Khachaturian
The answer is Shostakovich. Pulled in rehearsal in 1936.
Shostakovich's. In January 1936 Pravda published an unsigned attack on his opera, headed Muddle Instead of Music, after Stalin walked out of a performance. In that climate the article was not a review but a warning, and the Fourth Symphony was pulled during rehearsals; it was not performed until 1961.
He is said to have kept a packed suitcase by the door and slept on the landing so that an arrest would not wake his children. The Fifth Symphony followed as what a newspaper called a Soviet artist's reply to just criticism - a phrase he did not write - and its triumphant ending has been argued about ever since: sincere resolution, or forced rejoicing with a gun at the back of the head.
The evidence for reading his music as coded dissent mostly comes from a memoir published after his death whose authenticity is disputed, and the argument is not settled. What is not in doubt is the pressure: he was denounced again in 1948, wrote film scores and official cantatas to stay employed, joined the Party in 1960 in circumstances his friends described as a collapse, and signed his late works with a four-note motif spelling his own initials.